Husband, 46, killed by his wife's homemade curry after
suffering major allergic reaction to coconut cream.A man collapsed and
died after suffering an allergic reaction to his wife's homemade coconut
curry.
Marcus Sweet, 46, returned from work feeling fine to find his wife Julie preparing Indian food for their evening meal.
She gave him a small amount of her coconut cream to taste and within minutes he complained of a sore throat.
Mr
Sweet, a cleaning supervisor, took some Calpol and Beechams as he
started struggling to breathe, but his condition worsened and Julie
called an ambulance.
Mrs Sweet, of Stapleton, Bristol, told Flax
Bourton Coroner's Court: 'He was looking a little bit clammy and a bit
different. I told him he was starting to scare me.
'He said his throat was really sore and asked me to take him to hospital. I called an ambulance immediately.'
A paramedic arrived within four minutes of her call, but Mr Sweet's airwaves were closing and he began to turn blue.
Before he could be treated, he suffered a cardiac arrest and died, despite the arrival of more paramedics and an ambulance.
The inquest heard that Mr Sweet, who had one infant daughter, Courtney, had eaten coconut before but not coconut cream.
His
family accused Mr Vic Ward, the first responder who treated Mr Sweet,
of failing to act properly to save his life in November 2011.
They
claimed that Mr Ward ‘just sat there’ and the paramedic admitted to the
coroner: 'This was possibly one of the worst incidents I have ever
attended in my 30 years of work.
'I think I was a bit like a rabbit
in headlights for a couple of minutes before I reconciled what I did
next. It was stretching the boundaries of my experience.'
The inquest at Flax Bourton, near Bristol, heard that Mr Ward diagnosed Mr Sweet's condition as a reaction to the coconut cream.
He
treated it with an injection of the antihistamine Piriton, but minutes
later Mr Sweet went into anaphylactic shock, clutching his throat,
complaining he could not breathe.
His wife said: 'All of a sudden he just bolted upright like a meerkat and began to say he couldn’t breathe.
Fatal: Mr Sweet, a cleaning supervisor, was feeling fine when he came home from work earlier that day
Fatal: Mr Sweet, a cleaning supervisor, was feeling fine when he came home from work earlier that day
'Within
minutes of having the injection he was more clammy and he had
difficulty breathing. He made the horrible noise with his breathing. He
sounded like a death rattle.
'He was turning blue and his face had swollen and his tongue was sticking out.
'I
didn’t think he was going to recover from that. I looked at Vic Ward
and just thought "do something, for goodness sakes do something".'
Josephine
Needs, Mr Sweet’s mother-in-law who was also at the house for dinner
when he died, told the inquest: 'It was clear that Marcus wanted the
paramedic’s help but the paramedic was by the window with his back to
him.
'It looked like he was ignoring him. Marcus didn’t look a good
colour. He was clearly very, very unwell.'The inquest heard Mr Ward
moved to a lamp in the dimly-lit room to prepare an oxygen cylinder
after the injection.But as he did so, Mr Sweet fell off the sofa and
went into a cardiac arrest.
SELECTIVE ALLERGY: WHY PEOPLE CAN BE ALLERGIC TO COCONUT CREAM BUT NOT THE NUT ITSELF.
While
reactions to coconuts are relatively rare, an allergy to products
derived from the tree nut is more common.The reasons behind this vary
from person to person.
Often, it is a case of cross-reactivity.That
means the person is sensitive to a property present in a number of foods
- coconut, milk, and duck eggs - that is highly concentrated when
combined, for example in cream.In other cases, the person is in fact reacting to a chemical in the product, not the coconut itself.A short while later, back-up medics and an ambulance arrived and the crew administered CPR.
But after half an hour they were forced to stop and pronounced Mr Sweet dead.
The inquest was also told that Mr Sweet suffered from an undiagnosed heart condition which may have been a contributory factor.
Pathologist
Dr David Paterson said Mr Sweet died of acute respiratory obstruction,
acute laryngitis with mechanical and allergic inflammation, and coronary
artery atheroma.
Recording a narrative conclusion Coroner Maria
Voisin said: 'Marcus Sweet suffered an allergic reaction. Paramedics
were called but despite treatment he received he died.'
The
inquest heard paramedic Vic Ward had initially been suspended following
the death and had undergone extra training, but was now back at work.
Dr
Colin Holburn, a consultant in Accident and Emergency Medicine, told
the inquest that had Mr Ward acted quicker with the oxygen he probably
would not have prevented his death.
Giving evidence he said: 'Even if
he had given oxygen a minute before, when Mr Sweet had a compromised
air way, and we know he had a compromised heart, the cardiac arrest
might have happened because of the stresses of the anaphylactic shock.'
Yesterday,
widowed Julie Sweet criticised paramedic Vic Ward, claiming he was not
adequately trained for the job and had 'no sense of urgency at all'.
She
said: 'I feel angry that if I hadn't taken the time to contact the
coroner to say that something wasn't right and I hadn't complained to
the ambulance service, my husband's case would never have been
investigated.
'My main concerns were that Marcus was not given any oxygen, despite the fact that he was having difficulty breathing.
'Paramedic Vic Ward did not mention the possibility of giving oxygen at any point after he had arrived at the house.
'Furthermore,
he did not have a tongue depressor with him and had to ask me for a
spoon in order to look into the back of Marcus's throat.
'This indicated that he was not adequately prepared.
'Even when Marcus collapsed, Mr Ward seemed to do nothing and I felt that there was no sense of urgency at all.
'I
find it deeply worrying that he admitted that he was out of his depth
and it seemed to me that he wasn't adequately trained despite more than
30 years' experience.'
The family's solicitors Barcan Woodward said :
'It was very difficult for Mrs Sweet to hear Mr Ward, a paramedic,
admit that he was out of his depth despite having over 30 years'
experience.
'Her distress has been compounded by the fact that Mr Sweet's death, though tragic and sudden, may also have been preventable.
'Whilst
Mrs Sweet's pain will never subside, I do hope that this inquest has
provided our client and her family with some of the answers they have
waited so patiently for.'
No comments:
Post a Comment